"Why Put in This Much Effort?": How AI Availability Shapes Students’ Motivation in Introductory Programming

Created: 2026-06-30 | Tags: academic-integrityhigher-edllmover-reliancestudent-experience

Tran, Harper & Price (2026) — cs.CY 📄 Full text (arXiv)

Tran, Harper & Price (2026) examine a pressing motivational paradox in contemporary computing education: the ready availability of AI tools that can complete programming assignments undermines students' willingness to invest effort in developing their own skills. Drawing on self-determination theory, the study identifies how the perception of AI as a 'shortcut' reduces autonomous motivation and fosters a transactional orientation toward learning. The findings resonate with existing work on over-reliance and ai-assistance-reduces-persistence, suggesting that easy access to AI-generated code may erode the very persistence that produces deep learning. The paper has direct implications for course design: instructors must either redesign assessments to be AI-resistant or restructure motivation around goals that AI cannot fulfill. This connects to broader debates about academic-integrity in the age of generative AI and how student-experience of learning shifts when effort becomes optional. The study also highlights equity concerns — students who resist AI assistance may fall behind peers who use it, complicating assessment fairness in higher-ed.

Related Pages

Citation

APA: Keith Tran, Colton Harper, Thomas Price (2026). "Why Put in This Much Effort?": How AI Availability Shapes Students’ Motivation in Introductory Programming. arXiv:2606.30480. cs.CY.